The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading of the Odyssey by Seth Benardete

By Seth Benardete

During this fascinating interpretation of the Odyssey, the past due well known student Seth Benardete means that Homer can have been the 1st to philosophize in a Platonic feel. He argues that the Odyssey issues exactly the relation among philosophy and poetry and, extra greatly, the rational and the irrational in people. In mild of this hazard, Bernardete works backward and forward from Homer to Plato to ascertain the relation among knowledge and justice and attempts to get well an unique realizing of philosophy that Plato, too, recovered through reflecting at the knowledge of the poet. At stake in his argument is not any under the heritage of philosophy and the traditional knowing of poetry. The Bow and the Lyre is a e-book that each classicist and historian of philosophy may still have.


Show description

Read Online or Download The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading of the Odyssey PDF

Best literary criticism books

Metaphysics of the Profane: The Political Theology of Walter Benjamin and Gershom Scholem

Walter Benjamin and Gershom Scholem are considered as of the main influential Jewish thinkers of the 20th century. jointly they produced a dynamic physique of rules that has had an enduring effect at the research of faith, philosophy, and literary criticism.

Drawing from Benjamin's and Scholem's rules on messianism, language, and divine justice, this publication lines the highbrow trade during the early many years of the 20 th century--from Berlin, Bern, and Munich within the throws of warfare and revolution to Scholem's departure for Palestine in 1923. It starts off with a detailed studying of Benjamin's early writings and a learn of Scholem's theological politics, by way of an exam of Benjamin's proposals on language and the impression those principles had on Scholem's scholarship on Jewish mysticism. From there the booklet turns to their rules on divine justice--from Benjamin's critique of unique sin and violence to Scholem's software of the types to the prophets and Bolshevism. Metaphysics of the Profane is the 1st ebook to make this early interval on hand to a much broader viewers, revealing the elaborate constitution of this early highbrow partnership on politics and theology.

"The time period 'political theology' frequently invokes photographs of progressive political struggles caused by way of messianic or apocalyptic expectancies. As Eric Jacobson exhibits. .. such progressive Messianism. .. isn't really completely the province of Catholic liberation theology and Protestant theologies of desire, yet is usually attribute of the writing of 2 of the extra well known Jewish thinkers within the 20th century. … Jacobson's account of the early spiritual and political recommendations of Benjamin and Scholem is filled with illuminating insights into the interdependence of those thinkers, and into the individuality in their politics. " — Thomas A. James, magazine of Political Theology

Action et Réaction. Vie et Aventures d'un couple

Pourquoi dans l. a. vie quotidienne, affirme-t-on qu’une state of affairs intolérable appelle une réaction ? remark les biologistes en sont-ils venus à penser les rapports du vivant et du milieu en termes d’interaction ? Pour quelle raison los angeles psychiatrie a-t-elle adopté, il y a un siècle, l. a. catégorie des affections réactionnelles ?

The Muse Is Always Half-Dressed in New Orleans: and Other Essays

Codrescu's New Orleans is a layered global of mask that he gets rid of with no shrinking from both their horror or their demonic pleasure. This scented, vivid, corrupt, dreamy urban that "habla suneos" (speaks desires) is Codrescu's fertile floor. New Orleans, heritage and foreground, dressed and undressed, is the story-source of Codrescu's novels, "Messi@," "Wakefield," and "The Blood Countess.

Pretentiousness: Why It Matters

Pretentiousness is for somebody who has braved being diverse, even if that's creating a stand opposed to creative consensus or working the gauntlet of the final bus domestic dressed another way from each person else. It's an important element in pop track and excessive artwork. Why will we decide upon accusations of elitism over open-mindedness?

Extra resources for The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading of the Odyssey

Sample text

Whether the memory of terror is longer lasting than the memory of gratitude is another question. The action of the Odyssey had begun with Zeus’s recollection of Aegisthus, and how he had sent Hermes to warn him. Zeus now sends Hermes to Calypso, who under protest obeys the instructions Hermes transmits. 146–47). 102 [cf. 539). There is in the present time of the Odyssey nothing like the storm he once arranged at the Sun’s request. Perhaps Zeus can remain the father of men only if Odysseus ceases to be like a father to his people.

Telemachus’s willingness to stay at Sparta is a sign that Helen has convinced him that, if he is ever to meet his father, his father 30 Chapter Two must find him and not he his father. Odysseus is too mysterious to let himself be found out against his will. Menelaus never explains why he chose to wander for eight years with his five ships. 68–69). Menelaus picks up the story at the end of his wandering, when the gods detained him on the island of Pharos off the coast of Egypt. 41 He tells Eidothea—‘‘goddess of looks’’ or ‘‘goddess of knowledge’’—who took pity on him, that it was not because he took pleasure in suffering that he stayed on the island but because, without his knowing it, he must have sinned against the gods.

Athena’s presence is needed, apparently, to support such an understanding; she is not needed in any case at the home of Menelaus and Helen. It turns out that Nestor knows nothing about Odysseus since they parted ten years ago; Menelaus has the latest news, and his is two years old. Athena must have had more in mind than her stated purpose. 206–9). 123–25). Nestor puts side by side two different meanings of eoike: the semblance of Telemachus’ speeches to Odysseus’s (muthoi ge eoikotes) and the sensibleness of his speaking (eoikota muthe¯sasthai).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.57 of 5 – based on 32 votes