Military Power: Explaining Victory and Defeat in Modern by Stephen Biddle

By Stephen Biddle

In conflict, do mass and materiel topic so much? Will states with the most important, most sensible built, information-technology-rich militaries normally win? the existing solution this present day between either students and policymakers is definite. yet this can be to miss strength employment, or the doctrine and strategies during which materiel is really used. In a landmark reconception of conflict and battle, this e-book presents a scientific account of the way strength employment interacts with materiel to provide genuine wrestle results. Stephen Biddle argues that strength employment is vital to fashionable battle, turning into more and more vital on account that 1900 because the key to surviving ever extra deadly weaponry. Technological swap produces contrary results reckoning on how forces are hired; to concentration merely on materiel is hence to danger significant error--with severe effects for either coverage and scholarship.

In transparent, fluent prose, Biddle presents a scientific account of strength employment's function and indicates how this account holds up lower than rigorous, multimethod trying out. the implications problem a large choice of normal perspectives, from present expectancies for a revolution in army affairs to mainstream scholarship in diplomacy and orthodox interpretations of contemporary army history.

Military energy may have a convincing effect on either scholarship within the box and on coverage debates over the way forward for war, the dimensions of the army, and the make-up of the safety finances.

Show description

Read Online or Download Military Power: Explaining Victory and Defeat in Modern Battle PDF

Best military books

British Napoleonic Artillery 1793-1815 (2): Siege and Coastal Artillery (New Vanguard, Volume 65)

Following on from the 1st quantity overlaying British Napoleonic Artillery, this quantity concentrates at the heavy guns of siege and coastal defences. This e-book covers the most equipments used; the 24 pounder siege gun and numerous mortars. Mortars diversified from four- or 5-inch types as much as a13 inch calibre and have been thought of to be tremendous potent simply because they used an exploding shell to break fortifications or group of workers.

English Civil War Fortifications 1642-1651 (Fortress, Volume 9)

The innovations of eu conflict have been reworked throughout the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries via gunpowder and via enormous growth within the effectiveness and damaging strength of artillery. The sequence of conflicts within the 1640s, identified jointly because the English Civil struggle, was once the 1st within the British Isles that mirrored this new fact.

Forts of the American Frontier 1820-91: The Southern Plains and Southwest (Fortress, Volume 54)

Throughout the early a long time of the nineteenth century, the Southern Plains of the North American continent have been merely sometimes visited through explorers, trappers, investors, and missionaries. the 1st buying and selling posts and forts have been outfitted then, resembling Adobe partitions within the panhandle of North Texas, and Tubac Presidio in New Mexico.

German Battleships 1914-18 (2): Kaiser, König and Bayern classes (New Vanguard, Volume 167)

Supported through respectable files, own bills, legitimate drawings and specifically commissioned art, this quantity is an informative heritage of the most important periods Kaiser, König and Bayern that shaped the spine of the German Imperial army all through global warfare I, detailing the technological revolution that had taken position to let the construction of those huge dreadnought sessions.

Additional resources for Military Power: Explaining Victory and Defeat in Modern Battle

Example text

31 International relations theorists mostly ignore force employment. 34 A few have addressed force employment explicitly. The most important to date include John Mearsheimer’s use of an “attrition-blitzkrieg” strategic dichotomy to explain conventional deterrence, and Allan Stam’s, Dan Reiter’s, and D. 35 These are major improvements on the materially determinist treatments of capability in the literature at large. Yet they represent first steps rather than conclusive resolutions. “Attrition” and “blitzkrieg/maneuver,” for example, only scratch the surface of potentially meaningful distinctions in force employment; military doctrinal publications and military historiography consider an enormous array of other variations in the ways states have used their military forces.

40 Data on individual battles, rather than wars, yield no stronger results. 41 TECHNOLOGY Technology poses similar anomalies. To begin with, lethality and speed, the traits most analysts focus on, do not predict casualty or advance rates. 44 The specific claims of the systemic or dyadic technology schools also face difficulties. Systemic technology theorists hold that periodic shifts in prevailing technology induce secular shifts in the relative ease of attack and defense. 2 considers this claim by plotting the mean frequency of attacker victory in war by quarter-century using the COW data.

1 should thus show an important correlation between materiel and victory. The results, however, show a weak relationship. On average, flipping a coin would predict the outcome 50 percent of the time; a powerful theory should outperform a coin toss by a wide margin. Yet none of the five indicators predicted more than about 60 percent of the cases, and the indicator with the best apparent performance, GNP, is one for which very little data is available: its result is based on a sample of only about a dozen cases.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.34 of 5 – based on 25 votes
Posted In CategoriesMilitary